Have a collection of trading cards you’re looking to sell? Whether you’re clearing out old decks, making room for new ones, or just want some cash, we’re here to help. At Geekery Games, we buy Magic: The Gathering and Pokémon, making the process as smooth and transparent as possible.

Selling Your Cards In-Store

If you're local to Flagstaff and want to sell your cards in person, just bring them to the shop! No need to call ahead—simply stop by, and we’ll add your collection to our buy queue. One of our knowledgeable team members will evaluate your cards and present you with an offer. You can choose to be paid in cash or receive a higher value in store credit—perfect if you’re looking to trade up for new cards or sealed product.

Selling Your Cards Online

Not in Flagstaff or prefer to sell remotely? We’ve got you covered. Email us at info@geekerygames.com with details about the cards you're looking to sell, and we’ll guide you through the next steps. We make the process easy and hassle-free, ensuring you get a fair offer for your collection.

What We’re Buying

We buy singles, bulk, and sealed product from a variety of trading card games. High-value cards, tournament staples, and rare collectibles are always in demand. If you’re unsure whether your cards are something we’d purchase, don’t hesitate to reach out.

How We Determine Value

We base our prices on TCGPlayer Market if the cards are near mint condition. If they are less than that, we generally base prices closer to TCGPlayer Low. We grade cards based on TCGPlayer standards, as we are a TCGPlayer Direct Seller. Factors like card condition, edition, and demand all play a role in pricing, and we’re happy to walk you through how we arrive at our offers.

Why Sell to Geekery Games?

• Fast & Easy Process – No hassle, no waiting on online buyers.

• Fair Market Offers – We use the latest market data to price your cards competitively.

• Cash or Store Credit – Choose the payment method that works best for you.

• Support Your Local Game Store – Selling locally helps us keep the community thriving with events, tournaments, and a great selection of singles and sealed products.

Ready to Sell?

If you’re in Flagstaff, stop by the shop anytime! If you’re selling online, just send us an email at info@geekerygames.com, and we’ll get back to you with the details.